The Indiana FAIR Plan offers dwelling and commercial property insurance "to Indiana Residents who have been declined coverage by at least three non-related Insurance Companies." Its maximum is $250,000 for a dwelling risk and $1,000,000 for commercial coverage, each "combined for building and contents."[1] The plan says of itself that it "is designed to be used as a last resort to obtain basic property insurance."[1]
This guide is for an Indiana owner or landlord whose property insurers keep saying no, and the agent helping them. Our landlord insurance page lists what we need to quote, and our Indiana page shows the coverages we quote in the state today.
Who qualifies for the Indiana FAIR Plan?
Indiana residents declined by at least three insurance companies that are not related to each other. "The declination is verified in section 2 of the FAIR Plan application for insurance."[1] So keep the names of the insurers that turned you down. You will be asked for them.
What does the Indiana FAIR Plan cover, and how much?
| Type of risk | Maximum coverage |
|---|---|
| Dwelling | $250,000 combined for building and contents |
| Commercial | $1,000,000 combined for building and contents |
Both limits are the plan's own.[1] A home or building worth more than the limit is underinsured on the plan alone, which is one reason to keep shopping the private market.
Who runs the Indiana FAIR Plan, and who pays for it?
It is "a voluntary association comprised of insurance companies that are licensed to write property insurance in the State of Indiana." Funding comes "through premium income from FAIR Plan policies and if necessary, assessments paid by its member companies."[1] It is not a state agency and not a subsidy.
Should you try the private market first?
Yes. The plan says it "is not intended to be competitive with the voluntary insurance marketplace."[1] Ask for one more round of quotes, specialty insurers included, before you apply. For a rental house, see our landlord insurance page, and for tenants our Indiana renters insurance guide.
Have the property address, its year built, its use (rented, vacant, owner occupied) and the names of any insurers that declined it ready. Then start a rental property quote.
Frequently asked questions
How many declinations do I need for the Indiana FAIR Plan?
At least three, from insurance companies that are not related to each other, verified in section 2 of the application.[1]
What is the maximum coverage on the Indiana FAIR Plan?
$250,000 for a dwelling risk and $1,000,000 for commercial coverage, each combined for building and contents.[1]
Is the Indiana FAIR Plan run by the state?
It describes itself as a voluntary association of the insurance companies licensed to write property insurance in Indiana, funded by its policy premiums and, if necessary, assessments on those companies.[1]
Last reviewed November 19, 2026. This guide is general information. It summarizes the Indiana FAIR Plan's own website (Indiana Basic Property Insurance Underwriting Association), read on that date. It isn't legal advice. Menlo Insurance Services is a licensed insurance agency in Indiana that quotes landlord and rental dwelling insurance there and may earn a commission on a placement.
The Bottom Line
The Indiana FAIR Plan is real coverage with low ceilings: three declinations in, $250,000 or $1,000,000 at most.[1] Use it when you must, and ask a broker who works with specialty insurers before you do.
References
- 1.Indiana Basic Property Insurance Underwriting Association. “Indiana FAIR Plan.” Accessed 2026-11-19. https://www.indianafairplan.com/ ↩

